نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسنده
دانش آموخته حوزه علمیه، جامعه الزهرا، قم. ایران.
چکیده
کلیدواژهها
عنوان مقاله [English]
نویسنده [English]
This study examines the foundations and limits of the binding force of the obligations undertaken by an Islamic state through a comparative approach to the 1969 Vienna Convention and Imamiya political jurisprudence. Its central question is whether the binding nature of international obligations rests solely on the consent of states or whether their validity and continued force must also be assessed in light of substantive constraints and superior norms. Employing a descriptive, analytical, and comparative method, the study demonstrates that Article 53 of the Vienna Convention limits the will of states at the stage of treaty validity by reference to peremptory norms and considers treaties conflicting with the fundamental norms of the international public order void from the outset. Similarly, in Imamiya political jurisprudence, the nafy al-sabil (prohibition of domination) rule and related principles, including the preservation of Muslim dignity, the protection of independence, and the prohibition of subjection to domination, serve as prior criteria for assessing the legitimacy of obligations and exclude domination-producing commitments from the scope of the Lawgiver’s endorsement. With regard to the obligation to perform treaties, Article 26 of the Vienna Convention and the principle of asalat al-luzum (the presumption of binding force) in Imamiya jurisprudence both affirm the necessity of adhering to valid commitments. The difference, however, is that in Imamiya jurisprudence, the presumption of binding force applies only to legitimate obligations. Accordingly, Article 53 and the nafy al-sabil rule determine the limits of the validity and legitimacy of the source of an obligation, whereas Article 26 and asalat al-luzum concern the performance of valid obligations. By contrast, Article 27 prohibits invoking domestic law, at the stage of treaty implementation, as a justification for failure to perform a treaty. Therefore, the principles that define the Islamic state's religious and normative identity must be applied before an obligation is accepted, through domestic rules governing treaty-making competence, reservations, and interpretative declarations, rather than being invoked retrospectively as an excuse for non-performance. In this regard, the exception provided for in Article 46 limits recourse to domestic law to cases involving a manifest violation of a fundamental rule of internal law concerning competence to conclude treaties. Furthermore, the rule of fundamental change of circumstances under Article 62 and the concepts of a change in the subject matter of a ruling or the cessation of the underlying interest in Imamiya jurisprudence, despite their different foundations, perform functionally convergent roles in preventing the continuation of obligations that no longer have a justifiable basis. The study concludes that the binding force of an Islamic state's international obligations is not limited to the will of the parties. Rather, their validity rests on substantive legitimacy, while their continuation or termination is governed by the principles of treaty performance or by lawful mechanisms of modification and termination.
کلیدواژهها [English]