نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسندگان
1 دانش آموخته حوزه علمیه، سطح 3، استاد حوزه علمیه امام خمینی&، مشهد، ایران.
2 دانش آموخته حوزه علمیه، سطح 4، استاد و مدیر حوزه علمیه امام خمینی، مشهد. ایران.
چکیده
کلیدواژهها
عنوان مقاله [English]
نویسندگان [English]
Time-bound governmental decisions are measures issued by the Wali al-Amr (the Islamic ruler) on the basis of prevailing public interest and for the purpose of managing exceptional circumstances. Such decisions are binding at the time of their issuance. The fundamental question addressed in this study is what becomes of their binding force—that is, their munajjiziyyah (capacity to establish an obligation) and muʿadhdhiriyyah (capacity to serve as an excuse)—after a change in their subject matter or the cessation of the interest that gave rise to them, and what jurisprudential and principles-of-jurisprudence foundations justify their reconsideration or termination. Employing a descriptive-analytical method and an ijtihadi approach, this article examines Qur'anic and hadith-based evidence concerning guardianship and the ruler's duty to act in accordance with public interest, including the verse concerning obedience to those vested with authority, the verse on the best manner of managing an orphan's property, and the Letter of Imam Ali to Malik al-Ashtar. It then analyzes the jurisprudential principle that a ruling follows its subject matter, jurists' views on the distinction between a fatwa and a governmental ruling, and the positions of Imam Khomeini and Allameh Tabataba'i on changing and temporary regulations based on necessity. The findings indicate that the binding force of a governmental decision is dāʾir madār (contingent upon the continued existence of its underlying grounds) and operates in two stages. Its initial binding force arises when it is issued by a competent authority and its subject matter and underlying public interest have been established. Its continuing binding force remains in effect only as long as these essential grounds persist. The termination of a decision can occur according to four distinct patterns: explicit expiration, the disappearance of its subject matter, the cessation of its underlying public interest, and an initial error in establishing the subject matter or public interest. The first two patterns result automatically. In the third, because the assessment of public interest involves expert judgment, a determination by the competent authority and recourse to specialists are necessary; individual addressees cannot independently assume the authority to determine that the relevant interest has ceased. In the fourth, reconsideration leads to the annulment of the decision. In the first three patterns, termination does not have retroactive effect; it merely extinguishes the decision's continuing binding force. However, where termination is not self-evident, the cessation of its binding force in practice depends on appropriate notification. An addressee who has complied with the decision before its termination is announced is deemed excused, and the effects of actions already undertaken remain protected on the basis of the protection of legitimate expectations and the nafy al-darar (no-harm) rule. Moreover, if the continued enforcement of an obligation that no longer serves a legitimate public interest causes harm because the authorities have failed to monitor the relevant circumstances, the government is responsible for compensating the resulting loss. Beyond proposing this fourfold model, the article's contribution lies in identifying five criteria for reconsideration: explicitly specifying the grounds and duration of a decision; periodically monitoring the underlying public interest; distinguishing the assessment of the subject matter from the determination of the ruling; avoiding retroactive effects; and providing appropriate notification of termination. These criteria offer a practical framework for the reconsideration and termination of time-bound governmental decisions.
کلیدواژهها [English]