نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسنده
استادیار گروه حقوق، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی واحد رشت، رشت، ایران.
چکیده
کلیدواژهها
عنوان مقاله [English]
نویسنده [English]
The theory of the “Union of Islamic Republics,” proposed as a model for the political integration of Muslim societies, was developed in the author's previous study on the basis of the shared jurisp+rudential foundations of Islamic schools of thought and the experiences of contemporary composite states. That study proposed an intermediate model for moving beyond the dichotomy between a “centralized unitary state” and “limited cooperation among independent states.” Under this model, the member Islamic republics would retain their domestic independence and political identities while delegating some of their sovereign powers in shared policy areas to union institutions. The present article continues that line of inquiry but pursues a different objective: not to “propose” the theory, but to “test” it. Its fundamental question is whether the theory of the Union of Islamic Republics can withstand serious jurisprudential, legal, political, and religious criticism, or whether it is conceptually beset by irresolvable contradictions. To address this question, the article formulates four fundamental criticisms: a jurisprudential critique (the issue of wilayah and its relationship to the delegation of powers); a legal critique (the issue of national sovereignty and its compatibility with the constitutions of the member republics); a political critique (the question of ultimate authority and the risk of deadlock in times of crisis); and a religious critique (the issue of dual legitimacy and the incompatibility of the foundations of legitimacy across Islamic schools of thought). Using a descriptive-analytical method and drawing on jurisprudential and principles-of-jurisprudence sources, comparative constitutional law, and theories of federalism, the study demonstrates that all four criticisms are rooted in conceptual conflations: confusing wilayah (guardianship) with wikalah (delegation or agency); “sovereignty” with “competence”; a “personal ruler” with “legal sovereignty”; and “religious legitimacy” with “ummah-based legitimacy.” Once these concepts are redefined, it becomes clear that the Union of Islamic Republics neither violates the Guardianship of the Jurist (Wilayat al-Faqih), nor undermines national sovereignty, lacks an ultimate authority, or suffers from an insurmountable religious deadlock. The article concludes that the theory of the Union of Islamic Republics withstands the test posed by the four fundamental criticisms, provided that foundational sovereignty is distinguished from delegable powers, the transfer of powers is understood as a form of joint agency, the constitution is accepted as the ultimate authority, and the legitimacy of the union is defined on the basis of the Islamic ummah rather than any particular Islamic school of thought. Nevertheless, certain unresolved tensions—particularly concerning the interaction between the Supreme Council of Jurisprudence and the union institutions, as well as mechanisms for resolving conflicts among the legal opinions of different Islamic schools—require independent research and broader jurisprudential dialogue.
کلیدواژهها [English]